Things Every Songwriter Should Know
  ...from the Pros Who've Done it.

How Do You Know When You’ve Written a Great Song? 4 Steps to Help You Decide

Written by Barry DeVorzon – Follow us on Twitter

Not every song you write will be chart-topping material. That’s the business. Get used to the fact that every song you write won’t contain the emotional values needed to qualify it as a great song. A good song can be well done, well written, and musically well constructed, but that does not always mean that it’s great. Following the suggestions listed below will help you pick the winners.

1. Accept the fact that a song rarely starts out perfect.

When the heat of inspiration cools and you take your first look at a newly finished song, you have to accept the fact that the muse rarely leaves us with perfect. With that in mind, be forgiving and try and react to the essence of the song.

If the melody or the words, or the combination of the two touch you emotionally, then you have to assume that it will also touch others, and that’s what you’re looking for. Don’t let the sense of accomplishment that comes when you’ve created a new song get in the way of honestly reacting to it emotionally. This is a mistake that most amateurs make.

2. Great songs make people feel something.

Great songs have a quality that touches the emotions. There is no formula to accomplish this, it’s either there or it isn’t. If it isn’t there, it can never be a great song. A song can evoke any number of emotional responses -what’s important is that the listener feels something. If it makes you want to get up and dance or think of a lost love, or makes you feel anything, these are the responses you’re looking for.

3. How do those around you react to your song?

The first test of course is does it make you feel something? Next, test it with those close to you. Start with your wife, husband, girlfriend, boyfriend, or friends. I favor the wife or husband’s reaction over the others. It’s been my experience that they are usually the only ones who will really tell you the truth and the truth is what you’re looking for.

4. Be willing to do whatever it takes to make it better.

Once you’ve established that the song has the necessary ingredients to be great, it’s time to take it to the next level. If that means finding a more eloquent way of expressing yourself, finding a better chord, or adapting or modifying the melody, then do it. It can be painful and frustrating at times, but well worth it. Polish that beauty until it shines and you’re in the race.

There are no guarantees in this business.

Songwriting is like art–its beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The job of the songwriter is to be objective enough to make the song as perfect as possible, but in the end, how people emotionally respond to the song is all that matters. Everyone has an opinion about what makes a song great, but I believe it comes down to something that simple.

Simple…but not always easy to do.

Once you have a great song, the next step is recording a demo. Unfortunately, going into the studio with a great song does not necessarily mean you’ll come out with one. Next week we have another great story for you and the following week we will cover recording techniques.

How do you determine when you’ve written a great song? What qualities and reactions do you look for? Share in the comments below. Thanks for adding to the conversation.

Was this post helpful? If so, please share it with one other person who could use it. Use the links for Facebook and Twitter below. Thanks!

1,081 Responses to “How Do You Know When You’ve Written a Great Song? 4 Steps to Help You Decide”

  1. Really good site. Thanks so much for awesome article and your time in writing the posts.

  2. the primary casualty of battle is the fact renda extra envelopando

  3. Шикарно описана суть относительно моей дипломной работы, которую я собираюсь сдавать через
    3 дня :)

  4. Thanks very nice and useful.

  5. sultan says:

    It was a lot of good stuff. Thanks to your site

  6. Good day I am so glad I found your site, I really found you by error, while I was searching on Google for something else, Anyhow I
    am here now and would just like to say thanks for a tremendous post
    and a all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I
    don’t have time to look over it all at the minute but I have
    saved it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time
    I will be back to read a lot more, Please do keep up the awesome b.

  7. sultan says:

    nice . thank you the best website

  8. Panduan Dasar Permainan Judi Bola Online Istilah yang dipakai Judi Bola Online Indonesia

    MasterWriter Software | Blog

  9. Kém could hơn, sếp của bạn chỉ có 1 trong 2 điều đó.

  10. If some one desires expert view about blogging and site-building then i recommend him/her to visit
    this weblog, Keep up the nice work.

    My web site – Buzzing: SmartBuzzer from 4iTECH is
    a new buzzing device for brass musicians, http://www.facebook.com,

  11. Cuando en el ejercicio de las actividades clasificadas en este Grupo se faciliten a los alumnos libros artículos de escritorio, la cuota asignada al epígrafe correspondiente se incrementará en un 25 . Cuando en el ejercicio de las actividades clasificadas en este Grupo se preste el servicio de media pensión, la cuota asignada al epígrafe correspondiente se incrementará en un 25 .

  12. Alta calidad Made in Germany significa seguridad en la asistencia técnica también una vez hecha la compra. Grupo de empresas ubicado en Murcia con 15 años de experiencia en servicios industriales. Contamos con grandes profesionales en su ramo, pudiendo ofrecer desde servicios de venta y mantenimiento de maquinaria hasta servicios de informatica y comunicaciones orientados a profesionales de la industria. Empresa dedicada a la reparación de Maquinaria de Lavandería, Hostelería y Aire Acondicionado.

  13. Otra cosa importante es que las dos veces cuando envie un correo para saber el estado de la reparacion, al dia seguiente responden que ya esta reparado y enviado. Así que los SAT, que era tu pregunta, pues eso…, soy de la opinión de que poco más que sirven y saben sólo para cambiar piezas…, pero en líneas generales es lo que opino de todos. Bueno, ante todo contar mi experiencia con este servicio tecnico, ya que siempre contamos las cosas malas y cuando son buenas nos olvidamos. Tener que enviar el terminal al SAT no es plato de buen gusto para nadie, pero estos tiempos me parecen más que razonables.

  14. Xem bảng giá ở bên dưới để có thông tin chi tiết.

  15. thehill.com says:

    Ι like what yoᥙ guys are ᥙp also. Such clever work and reporting!
    Keep up the excelⅼent ѡorks guys I’ve incorporateⅾ y᧐u guys to my
    blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my site :).

    Feel free toօ surf to myy weblog; Tribal loans (thehill.com)

  16. Climatemp ofrece a sus clientes una amplia variedad de marcas entre las que se encuentran FUJITSU, KAYSUN, MITSUBISH, GENERAL DAIKIN. En TSclima ofrecen una amplia y completa gama de productos para instalaciones de energía solar térmica, fotovoltaica y sistemas de climatización, así como una serie de servicios complementarios y soporte técnico a nuestros clientes.

  17. CNC acero says:

    Entre los problemas comunes que nos hemos encontrado en Parla podemos garantizar la solución inmediata de los siguientes: Apagones, sobrecarga de la red, reparación de enchufes e interruptores, existe un enchufe sin corriente, salta el interruptor diferencial, la tarifa nocturna no carga, salta frecuentemente el limitador de potencia, diferenciales y cualquier derivación, parte de la vivienda local sin luz.

  18. Professional Network Administration

    MasterWriter Software | Blog

  19. Estamos autorizados para la realización de todo tipo de servicios que guarden relación con el gas, realizando el trabajo solucionando el problema en muy poco tiempo. Cualquier instalador profesional gas Daganzo de nuestra empresa usara siempre las técnicas menos invasivas, los mejores materiales y las herramientas de mayor calidad, lo que hará que el trabajo se pueda realizar en mucho menos tiempo, pero de una forma más eficaz y con garantía. Instalación y Reparación de: Calderas de Gas, Calderas Eléctricas, precios economicos en Daganzo para sus Calderas de Gas-Oil, Calentadores y Termos.

  20. Siguiendo las directrices de la Agencia Española de Protección de Datos procedemos a detallar el uso de cookies que hace esta web con el fin de informarle con la máxima exactitud posible. Realizamos mecanizado de piezas unitarias y pequeñas series para pedidos bajo plano, muestra geometrías procesables con sistemas CAD.

  21. thc cbd oil says:

    There are difcferent makes on this product and folks dsploying it wll want to look with the list of ingredients tto
    check the purity of the product. How to Make Money with
    Versativa Network – To get the full benmefit with thhe pay plan, a whole new distributor joining should select the “all a single combo upgrade pack” costing
    $540. We are raising are children to become wastefhl and greedy
    that’s so saad since many many chyildren can’t even eat today.

  22. روبیکا says:

    Entre los problemas comunes que nos hemos encontrado en Parla podemos garantizar la solución inmediata de los siguientes

  23. Carpenter’s anole

    MasterWriter Software | Blog

  24. Jonathan says:

    Various techniques of off page search optimization – Jonathan – are press announcements, article distribution,
    online marketing, linking with social networks,
    through link exchanges, blogging, banner and forum posting
    etc. So what can you will definitely do in order to help make your web business more popular.
    Do niche research to locate narrow keyword phrases associated with your niche and
    rehearse them as titles for your pages.

  25. Margot says:

    Делается это при помощи одной лишь кнопки за секунду.

    Here is my page; message33840; Margot,

  26. Therefore ensure that you create a viable budget without
    compromising for the quality of the bookmarks. SB is a
    great tool that has huge prospect of traffic generation and boosting your internet site
    to stardom in no time. If you’re using a website and you also are not doing efforts to promote it then it’s worthless to have a very site.

  27. Jack says:

    I won’t be reluctant to suggest your web page to anyone who would like guide on this situation.

  28. If some one needs expert view about blogging after that
    i suggest him/her to pay a quick visit this weblog, Keep up the pleasant job.

  29. پروویدئو دانلود فیلم و سریال

  30. تکچینک says:

    فروشگاه انلاین

  31. Retha says:

    Think about something you fear doing and do it.

  32. Ӏ got thіs website frօm my buddy who informed me about ths wweb ⲣage and now tһis time I amm browsing this website аnd reading
    very informative posts here.

  33. Charissa says:

    Each person’s healing journey is unique.

  34. It is related to the idea of self-gratification.

Leave a Reply